PROTECTION OF THE CHILD FROM DEGRADING
TREATMENT IN TANZANIA: A CRITICAL ASSESSMENT OF THE LAW AND PRACTICE
Kevin Mandopi1
1 PhD - Ruaha University College (A Constituent of Saint Augustine University of Tanzania-SAUT), LLM, LLB - UDSM, Lecturer - Institute of Judicial Administration Lushoto, Advocate of the High Court of Tanzania, Email: kmandopi6@yahoo.com.
|
|
ABSTRACT |
Keywords: Protection; Degrading; Treatment; Tanzania; |
|
The child should be protected by his rights.
Protection of child rights and welfare makes the child able to reach his physical, mental, emotional and
social potentials. The child needs to be provided with necessary services for
his growth from his parents, relatives and the State. The study by Legal and
Human Centre reveals that: There
has been an increase of violations of the rights of children in Tanzania.
Tanzanian children are seriously vulnerable to cruelties of all forms,
including sexual offences, physical and emotional neglect, physical abuse,
child labour, and even murder. Rape incidences account for about 75% of the
reported.’ Thus, the child needs
to be protected against torture and degrading treatments, involving in
different pornographic activities, sexual exploitation, drug abuse, and
trafficking of drugs, child trafficking, child sale, abduction, degrading
fosterage and adoption. The Public Enquiry on Violence and Abuse against
Children conducted in eleven Districts in Tanzania to a total number of 307
cases revealed that the child highly suffers from degrading treatment. Thus,
appropriate measures are required to be set on place with a view of
protecting the child against degrading treatment. Publisher All rights reserved. |
PROTECTION AGAINST TORTURE AND
DEGRADING
TREATMENT
The international
legal instruments for child rights have prohibited the imposition of torture,
cruel, inhuman, degrading treatment or punishment to the child. Child “torture” has been explained to mean; ‘...any
act by which severe pain or suffering, whether physical or mental, is
internationally inflicted on a person for such purposes as obtaining from him
or a third person information or confession, punishing for such purposes as
obtaining from him or third person information or a confession, punishing him
for an act he or a third person has committed or is suspected of having
committed, or intimidating or coercing him or a third person, or for any reason
based on discrimination of any kind, when such pain or suffering is inflicted
by or at the instigation of or with the consent or acquiescence of a public
official or other person acting in an official capacity. It does not include
pain or suffering arising only from, inherent in or incidental to lawful
sanctions.’
Therefore, this definition shows clearly that, torture can be in the form
of mental or physical. These kinds of torture affect the health of the victim.
In relation to mental state, torture affects the psychological position of the
victim to which its healing is very difficult because requires medical
treatment and psychological experts. However, this definition seems to cover
the general aspects of torture, but the existence of article 1(2) of the Convention against Torture and other
Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment, allowing the domestic law
to make its own definition of torture seems to justify torturing. The State may use this law to justify
torturing done in a view of getting some information or confession from the
suspects. This may waive the intention
of article 1(1) of the Convention against Torture. Unjustifiably suspects are
normally bittern and exposed to torture in disregarding various rights of human
being under the umbrella of making investigation on the matter alleged to have
been committed. Child torture has different forms like beating, sexual torture,
electric torture, burning, and any other form of torture. All these forms of torture violate child
humanity.
Tanzania has enacted the law prohibiting any person to subject a child to
torture, or other cruel, inhuman punishment or degrading treatment to any
child. The law also prohibits torture
originates from cultural practice which dehumanises or is injurious to the
physical and mental well-being of a child.
The effort of taking legislative enactment in Tanzania should be
accompanied by administrative, social, and educational measures with a view to
protect the child from all forms of torture, inhuman or degrading treatment
especially physical, mental injury, abuse, neglect or maltreatment. These measures are expected to combat
different kinds of child torture.
However, these measures seem to be not enough adopted in Tanzania, as
the child is not well protected from abuse.
Tanzania needs to take active child protective measures providing an
effective procedures for the establishment of special monitoring units to
provide necessary support for the child and for those persons who have the care
of the child. The monitoring should include various forms of prevention, identification,
reporting referral investigation, treatment, and follow-up of instances of
child abuse and neglect. These
monitoring must be done by the competent experts with a view of protecting the
child against any child abuse.
The principle of protecting the child against torture also applies in the
administration of juvenile justice. It is paramount that, the child having
infringed penal law has the right to special treatment in a manner consistent
with the child's sense of dignity, worth and which reinforces the child's
respect for fundamental human rights and freedom. The correction measures against the child
ought to consider the age, physical and mental condition of the child. The rationale of imposition of correction
measures should be understood by the convicted juvenile offender. In case the
child does not understand, the nature of the correction measures to be imposed
cannot be imposed against him. The child needs to be protected against all
forms of child degrading. The person who
torture, or practice cruelty, uses inhuman punishment or provides degrading
treatment against the child contravenes the law. In Tanzania in some occasion
children are beaten on arrest, while are in police custody or under the
prisons. Generally torturing the child
is an offence and on conviction will be liable to a fine not exceeding five
million shillings or to imprisonment for a term not exceeding six months or to
both.
PROTECTION AGAINST CHILD PORNOGRAPHY
AND SEXUAL
EXPLOITATION
Both child
pornographic materials and sexual exploitation are prohibited activities under
the law. Child pornography and sexual
exploitation spoiling the health, physical, mental, social and moral values of
the child. The law prohibits the child to be engaged in any business that
exposes the child to activities of sexual nature, whether paid for or not. To date child pornography materials are
rampant due to the presence of computer technology which encourages pornography
material storage, transmission and access.
The child and adult persons watches porn materials through computers
where the child is not protected by law against such abuse. This causes the child to be abused his rights
for lack of specific laws protecting the child from computer misuse. For that
reason, the State should respond appropriately in protecting the child against
dealing in pornography materials.
Therefore, it is unlawful for any person to apply any inducement,
encouragement of a child to engage in any sexual activity prostitution or other unlawful sexual
practices. Also the child should not be
exposed into pornographic performances or materials. This is totalling immoral to the child and
hinders the wellbeing of the child. This is a rapid growing problem in the
societies all over the world including Tanzania. Hence, strong measures ought to be taken by
the government and other responsible authorities in protecting the rights of
the child against such abuse.
In making sure the
child is well protected from such calamities the law criminalises any person
who exposes the child to pornographic and prostitution activities. In case
there is any person found guilty of this offence by the court might be
condemned to pay a fine of not less than one million shillings and not more
than five hundred million shilling or to imprisonment for a term of not less
than one year and not more than 20 years or both. This is in the efforts of prohibiting the use
of child pornography material and involving the child into child pornographic
production and prostitution activities.
Despite Tanzanian laws providing for penal sanctions but still the child is
exposed into streets especially a girl child where is involved into
commercialised prostitution and pornographic materials production
activities. The reason claimed is
poverty. But in real sense there are a number of reasons promoting the child
abuse. Such reasons include, lack of proper care afforded to the child by the
parents, guardians, or relatives. Also the moral decay of the members of the
society motivates the adult person using the child in prostitution and
production of pornographic materials.
Low education on HIV or AIDS and
the effects of prostitution and pornographic materials encourages the child abuse
in Tanzania. It has been also said that,
the other reason is ineffectiveness of the laws enforcement machinery in
protecting the child against the prostitution and phonographic materials. These
reasons make the child to involve in the prostitution and pornographic
activities. The child is in streets, takes food in streets and sleeps in
streets where is exposed into dander of engaging into pornographic and abusive
prostitution. The law enforcement system knows the streets where the child
involves in prostitution sometimes with adults but no action is taken with a
view of protecting the rights of the child. This makes the continuation of
prostitution and pornographic activities to continue against the interest and
welfare development of the child.
Lack of appropriate measures to protect the rights of the child cause the
child to be abused sexually. Thus the Penal Code expressly criminalises such acts. The law
makes a criminal offence for any person permitting, or inducing the child for
the purposes of causing a child to be sexually abused or to participate in any
form of sexual activity, any obscene or indecent exhibition. It is also an offence for any person to
encourage a person to be a client of a child for sexual intercourse, or
indecent exhibition by means of print or media, oral advertisements or other
similar means. Principally, no one is
allowed under the law to take advantage of his influence over, or his
relationship with the child. This
include to threatens, use violence towards the child, give monetary consideration, goods or other
benefits to the child or his parents with intention of procuring the child for
sexual intercourse, any form of sexual abuse or indecent exhibition. In case any person is found to be guilt of an
offence of sexual exploitation of the child should be sentenced to imprisonment
for a term not less than five years and not exceeding twenty years. This is a
great punishment and it has been set for protecting the child from sexual
exploitation. Also it is important that, the sexual organs of the child should
be protected from any abuse by any person.
But it has been noted that, this provision of law is toothless. The
child is experiencing sexual exploitation daily but no one is taken to task
through the law.
In case there is a person, for his sexual gratification, using his genital,
any other part of the human body or any instrument, interferes with any sexual
organ of the child which does not amount to rape, commits the offence of grave
sexual abuse. Generally, the child should also be protected from sexual
harassment. Sexual harassment arises when a person with intention, assaults the
child by the use of words or actions, or causes sexual annoyance to the
child. These actions also have been
criminalised under the penal law. In the
case of Gaurav Jain v. Union of India the court directed that: The government and all non- governmental
organisations have duty to take necessary measures for the protection of the
child from prostitution and provide rehabilitation measures; the child ought to be provided with proper
services including accommodation with a view of protecting the child from
sexual abuse; and the child involved
into sexual abuse and pornographic materials should be provided with the
rehabilitation methods so as to make the child be in a normal state of affair
in relation to health, physical and mental, towards the acquisition of the
child development.
It is sad to say that, the activities relating to pornographic materials,
prostitutions, sexual harassment, defilement, unnatural offences and the like
are still gaining momentum in Tanzania despite of presence of laws and various
lamentation of child protection from such abuse. For instance, Benedict
Kilembe, an adult person of Lyamile Nyeregele Village Mbarali Mbeya committed
the offence of unnatural offence against the infant girl of aged three years.
Benedict Kilembe was convicted and sentenced for life imprisonment for the
offence committed. Similarly, Shabani
Edward a boy estimated to be below 18 years by Mbeya High Court, as well was
convicted for raping a girl aged 12 years at Nanyaki Village at Mbeya. Shabani
Edward initially was convicted for life imprisonment but the High Court of
Mbeya reduced to corporal punishment which later was set aside to the reason
that, the offender already had served four years in prison. The child abuse incidences have been spread
all over the country not only at Mbeya. Karim Abdallar @ Likowe an adult
person, resident of Lindi was convicted for raping a girl child aged six to
eight years. Likowe as the result was sentenced to life imprisonment which later
the sentence was confirmed by the Court of Appeal of Tanzania. The Dodoma High Court also got an opportunity
of convicting one Mohamed Yusuf, an adult person, resident of Uzunguni Kikulo
Village, Kondoa Dodoma for raping a child girl aged seven years. Mohamed Yusuf
as the result was sentenced to life imprisonment. Not only the offences of rape and unnatural
offences committed against the child. Octavian Makota, an adult person was
convicted for an offence of defilement against a girl aged 12 years, as the
result the accused was sentenced to 12 years imprisonment and ordered to pay
compensation of 20,000 to the victim.
All these incidences of sexual offences show clearly that, still there
is sexual abuse to the child in Tanzania. Such abuses are committed by the
adult persons and sometimes committed by a child himself against his fellow
child. All these kinds of abuse should
be stopped with a view of protecting and promoting the rights of the child in
Tanzania.
Despite having the law in place for protecting the child from prostitution
and engage into pornographic activities, but still the rights of the child
remains abused. The child always is abused in streets and in various parts in
the country. That is in rural and urban places where the child is used by his
fellow child and adults in prostitution and production of pornographic
materials. The existences of rampant and
uncontrolled internet cafes have accelerated the child to watch pornographic
materials and indulge into the prostitution activities. The availabilities of
television and sexual movies has open the black door to the child to watch and
learn various styles of sexual intercourse and the way of taking pornographic
photographs and movies. This causes the child being spoiled to an extent that, the
health, physical, mental capabilities, social disorder, and the social welfare
development of the child is affected.
The protection of the child from prostitution and pornographic activities
should be extended and afforded to the child when is in conflict with law. From
arrest, prosecution, sentencing, and serving the sentence, the juvenile
offender should not be exposed into the environment which is possible to
practice sexual exploitative behaviour including the use of pornographic
materials. But the Commission of Human Rights and Good Governance has pointed
that, children are abused sexually by adult prisoners, fellow children, and
custody officials in the system of administration of justice especially in
those places where children are not separated from adults. However, the child when is in custody whether
at the police station, prison or approved school should not be sexually
exploited. This is possible when the child is not mixed up with adults and
other habitual or exploitative offenders. The principle of the best interest of
the child also extended into the way of protecting the child when is in
conflict with law by placing the child into the environment that motivates the
child welfare development.
PROTECTION AGAINST HARMFUL LABOUR
AND DEGRADING
ENVIRONMENT
The child should
be protected from harmful labour and degrading environment. The Employment and Labour Relations Act,
2004 prohibits any person to employ a
child under the age of 14 years. But the
child of 14 years of age have been permitted to be employed to do only light
works which are not harmful to the health of the child and his
development. Such works should not
affect the child's attendance to school, participation in vocational
orientation or training programmes approved by the competent authority. In other words, "light work"
constitute work which is not likely to be harmful to the health or development
of the child. The light work must be the work which does not prevent and affect
the child's attendance at school, participation in vocational orientation or
training programmes and the capacity of the child to benefit from school
work. It is significant to provide out
that, the child should not be employed to work in big plantation like Mufindi
tea plantations, working in fish industries, mines like Mererani, Kahama, and
Geita mines. The child is working in
these hash environments without protective measures such as clothes and social
security services including medical services.
This makes the child into the dangerous environment which deteriorates
the child welfare development.
The child should be provided with light works which is beneficial to the
child himself. It is also provided that, a child under 18 years of age should
not be employed in hazardous works like:
Going to fishing; mining and
quarrying; porterage of heavy loads; manufacturing industries where chemicals are
produced or used; work in places where
machines are used; and work in place
such as bars, hotels and places of entertainment. Prohibition of such works is done with a view
of protecting the welfare of the child.
These works are counted to be harmful to the welfare of the child as
affect the health, education, mental, physical, or moral development of the
child. The child should not perform even
the normal activities like agriculture, where a work condition is
hazardous. The child should not be
working in tea, coffee, sugar, and cotton plantations. These works challenges
the welfare development of the child.
It is generally prohibited to employ
a child to work in places which is considered to be inappropriate for a child
taking into account of his age. These
places are considered to be risk to the child's well-being, education,
physical, mental health, spiritual, moral or social development. Generally employing the child in
contravention of law is an offence under the law itself. The child should be permitted to work on the
board of a training ship, and in a
factory or a mine if that work is part of the child's training. The child is also allowed to work in any
other worksites on condition that the health, safety, and moral values of the
child are fully protected by the trainers. To this regard, the child should be
provided and receives an adequate specific instruction or vocational training
relevant to the work concern. It is
imperative to point that, the employer or trainer, ought to know the exact age
before deciding exposing the child to any work. This is due to the fact that,
in any proceedings where the age of the child is in issue, the burden of
proving that the child was not under age lies on the person employing or that
procures the child for employment or training.
This creates necessity for the child to be known his exact age before
employing or committing the child to any training. This is normally possible to
be done when the employer in any industrial place keeps a register of children
employed at the working station. The register should contain information
relating to the dates of birth.
The law further prohibits any forced labour to the child. The child should not be forced to do any work
whether harmful or not to the child. It
is also prohibited to employ or engage a child in any kind of exploitative
labour. The exploitative labour has the
following characteristics: It deprives the child of his health and his general
development; is the work which requires
a child to work over six hours a day; it
is inappropriate to the child, taking into account his age; and the child is paid inadequate remuneration
for the work he does. The law requires a
child to be paid remuneration equal to the value of the work done. Non-payment
of the child as required by law is the contravention of the rights of the
child. In case there is a person
exercising an exploitative labour to the child commits an offence under the
law. In case such person is arrested and convicted by the court may be
subjected to a fine of not less than one hundred thousand shillings or to
imprisonment for a term of three months or both. This penalty has been provided under the law
with a view of protecting the welfare of the child and promoting the child
toward development. In case the child has been lawfully employed should be
protected against any discrimination or acts which have negative effect to the
child. The duty of protecting such child
is placed to the shoulders of the employer.
As stipulated above, the law prohibits employing the child who is below 14
years of age. However, in Tanzania there are still employers employing the
child to work in various works. There
are many reasons causing the employers and the child himself to be ready
employed into various works although the law prohibits. Such reasons include:
low education qualifications, this motivates the child to engage himself into
low paying employments; marriage breakdown, this sometimes causes the child to live
without enough control from the parents and other relatives. This also
contributes the child engaging himself into employment prohibited under the
law. Low family income makes the child to fail getting the necessary services
like food and clothes, something which encourages the child to be employed even
into the hazardous environment with a view of getting income which will
supplement the important services at the family level. Again, the existing
migration of children from rural to urban areas creates the child remains in
streets where encourages the child into the exploitative employment. Likewise,
the employers always search for high profit, this encourages employing the
child because normally is paid low remuneration. All these contribute the child to be employed
into the works which are harmful and hazardous to the child. This motivates the
child to be employed and be working into mining, manufacturing industries,
working in machines, bars, hotels, big plantations and working in porterage
heavy loads where sometimes ended to be sexually abused.
The parents, guardian, relatives, and the society in general, do not take
strong steps to protect the child against harmful employments. This causes the
child to be employed in such employments where his rights are abused.
Discussing the spread of the child labour in Tanzania, Shivji states that:‘A
recent ILO-IPEC study has noted that in the rural areas, more than 25,000
out-of school children are estimated to be working under hazardous conditions
either in commercial agriculture or on mining and quarry sites. The study
states that 40% of primary school age children interviewed at Mtibwa in
Morogoro region indicated that they were working on the part-time basis at the
Mtibwa sugar-cane plantation under hazardous conditions and with little pay, in
order to buy school uniform and other requirements.’
Therefore, despite poverty among the parents and the greedy of the
employers to look for cheap labour but also it has been noted that, the society
do not have enough educational awareness of various laws prohibiting the child
to be employed especially into the harmfully environment. The State and the community at large should
play their role in protecting the child. Also the efforts should be taken to
provide awareness to the community on the need of protecting the child from
hazardous employments.
The child also should be protected when is in conflict with law. During the
entire process of the administration of juvenile justice the child should not
be exposed to the hazardous labour. The child ought to be treated in a manner
that takes into consideration the child health, age, physical and mental
potentials. The sentences which might be imposed to the child offender should
not attract in exposing the child into hazardous environments. The child should
be handled in the manner that takes into board the need of the child welfare
development. This can be met by emphasising educational and vocational
trainings be provided to the child in conflict with law with a view of
promoting the rehabilitation mechanism and psychosocial measures to the
juvenile offender rather than emphasising the hard labour. These programmes will assist making the child
into proper reintegration with the family and members of the society when goes
out of the systems of justice.
PROTECTION OF THE CHILD AGAINST DRUG
ABUSE AND DRUG TRAFFICKING
The child is
vulnerable and is easily subjected to drug abuse and drug trafficking.
According to N.V. Paranjape, drug abuse;
‘...may be
conceptualised as crime without victim, i.e addict himself is the victim who
becomes a prey of its misuse. This devastating melody is eroding the roots of
social, economic and cultural fibre...It gives rise to criminality and criminal
behaviour which eventually leads to social disorganisation.’
The child drug abuse has been rampant in various streets in urban places.
The child uses drugs as part of leisure and relaxing and relieving physical and
mental tensions. Sometimes the child takes drugs as part of his daily
life. The expansion of drug
manufacturing industries, growth of town and cities had promoted the use and
trafficking of drugs. In the process of doing such harmful business the child
becomes part of trafficking, selling and using of drugs. A child normally after
using drugs continue committing other criminal acts like petty crime,
prostitution, robbery, house lifting and other related crimes. Drug abuse
generally destroys the child health, physical, mental and social development.
This makes the child a victim of his misdeed.
The child puts himself in the drug abuse due to the number of causes, which
include: The development in industries and urbanisation has accelerated the
easy availability of drugs and the interaction of person of various characters
hence contributed the child to adopt such harmful behaviour in his detriment;
the interaction of cultures has created the child at early stages taking and
using drugs as a fashion and enjoyment but at the same time remains addicted
hence becomes the victim of drugs user; lack of parental care and control is
the other reason for child drug abuse, the child lacks supervision and
direction and falls into the hands of drug users where the child puts himself
in the group of drugs users; lack of awareness of the effects of using drugs
among the children also promotes using drugs prevalence of drugs in the
society; most of the parents and the members of the society lacks child
psychology, which contributes in creation of gap between the child and the
parent where by the parent fails to identify at the early stages the life and
character of his child thus the child ends up to be affected by drugs.
The child may normally be affected by using various types of drugs
including narcotic drugs which contain the following ingredients: Opium and its
derivatives such as heroin and codeine; cocoleaf and cocine; and methadene,
pethedine, hebaine. The other group of
drugs is psychotropic substance which includes valium, diazepam, and morphine.
All these drugs affect the welfare of the child. In the process of protecting
the child against drugs abuse in Tanzania various laws has been enacted.
Section 17 of the Law of the Child, prohibits any person who runs a
discotheque, bar or night club, to allow a child to enter into such
premises. The law does not allow the
child in such premises or to be employed or provided with any services in such
premises. The law also prohibits any person to sell cigarettes, alcohol, any
spirit, drugs or any intoxicating substance to a child. Where there is a person who contravenes these
prohibitions commits an offence and upon conviction he should be liable to pay
a fine not less than one million shillings but not exceeding five million
shillings or to imprisonment for a term not exceeding 12 months or to
both. Commenting on the efficiency of
the laws controlling drug abusers N.V. Paranjape, remarks, ‘experience has
shown that various preventive and punitive measures such as fine, imprisonment,
or detention for…disorderly behaviours have failed in eliminating this menace.’
Therefore, since, the law seems to fail to combat against child drug abuse
then, the child who is found to have been committed the offence should be
reformed and not to be punished. Likewise, people should be educated on the
effect of exposing the child to drugs. Such education might be the cure against
the child drug abuse as the child will not be exposed to drugs.
The law in Tanzania puts prohibition of possession and trafficking of
narcotic drugs and psychotropic substances and cultivation of certain plants
which has relation to drugs. Principally,
the child should not be involved into cultivation of any of the following:
Cannabis, coca plant, or gathers any portion of coca plant; and cultivation of Papaver Somniferous (opium
poppy) or papaver setigerum. Likewise,
the child should not be involved in any manner in production, possession,
transportation, and importation of drugs in Tanzania. To involve the child in dealing with drugs in
whatever capacity is spoiling the welfare of the child. The child also should
not be involved in the entire process of selling, purchasing, and using
drugs. All these acts are criminalised
under the law. The involvement of the child in any manner to drugs such as
poppy straw, coca plants, coca leaves, prepared opium, opium poppy, cannabis,
manufacturing of drugs or any preparation containing any manufactured drug,
psychotropic substance, narcotic drug all such acts amounting to contravention
of the provisions of law. In case the child dealer of drugs is found guilty of
drugs offence, may be penalised to pay a fine of one million shillings or three
times the market value of the prohibited plant, whichever is the greater, or to
imprisonment for a term not exceeding 20 years or both the fine and
imprisonment.
Despite of the existence of law, the child is still exposed to the drug
abuse calamity. As the result of drugs sometimes the child is addicted. This is
a stage where the child is demonstrating impaired control in relation to the
use of that drug, or drug-seeking behaviour suggesting such impaired control.
In another way the child cessation of the administration of the drug is likely
to result in experiencing symptoms of mental or physical distress or
disorder. In this occasion the child
becomes a victim of drugs and the court as well should treat such kind of child
like a victim and not like an offender.
The law establishes clearly that where any addicted child is found guilty
of an offence relating to drugs and the court is on opinion that, taking into
consideration of the age, character, antecedents, physical or mental condition
of the offender that, it is expedient so to do, then the court should instead
of sentencing the offender at once to any imprisonment, with the consent of the
offender, the court has power to direct that, the offender be released for
undergoing medical treatment for detoxification or de-addiction.The treatment
must be taken from the hospital or an institution recognised by the
Government. But the order of releasing
the offender to the treatment requires the offender entering into a bond in the
form prescribed by the Commission. Such bond may be with or without sureties
and the court should direct the offender to appear and furnish before the court
within a period not exceeding three months, a report regarding the result of
offender medical treatment. The court also has power to direct that, while the
juvenile is undertaking the medical treatment should abstain from commission of
any offence relating to drug abuse. In
case the offender has been released for hospital treatment fails to comply with
the condition for abstaining from commission of an offence then the court can
order the offender to appear before the court where other sentences should be
imposed. Normally, the sentences which
should be imposed to such child ought to have rehabilitative effect and which
encourages the child welfare development.
Taking into consideration the age, character, antecedents, physical or
mental condition of the offender it is obvious that the child should be
protected from any form of mistreatment. Where the child is addicted then the
welfare development of such child is affected. In such occasion the
administration of juvenile justice system should take and consider the child as
a victim who requires the rehabilitative measures and not handling the child as
an accused person. It is advised that, the rehabilitation should not be
conducted away from the child family.
Despite, Tanzania taking the action of enacting the law to combat drug
abuse, this is not the only measure. The State should take other active measures
which include: Developing and implementing a national plan of action for drug
control; implementing the provisions of
International Conventions on Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances; and updating drug control laws, regulations
and establishing the proper system of its enforcement. Also the State should establish the mechanism
of promoting the prevention of drug abuse and public information for
youngsters, families, educators, the public, by supporting other initiatives in
the field of information and prevention. Likewise, the efficiency of law and
the enforcement machinery should be well established to prevent prevalence of
drugs and drug dealers. Again, the
strategies of establishing a viable data collection and analysis system at the
national level on drug abuse, drug trafficking
and developing treatment, rehabilitation programmes for drug
addicts and undertaking research on drug
addiction. These measures assist to
protect the child from drug abuse. However, these measures are not exhaustive.
Other measures include establishing trainings to personnel in-charge of
strategies for dealing with drug abuse, drug trafficking, money laundering
precursors, promoting and ensuring
international co-operation, and ensuring
co-ordination and support of activities of non-government organisations and
associations participating in drug abuse control. Therefore, various people should be provided
with the educational programmes of the effects of the drugs and the object of
protecting the child from drug abuse. However, efforts should be done with a
view of early detecting the drug dealings to the child with a view of
protecting the child from being addicted. When these efforts taken on board
will lead the child being protected to the best interest of the child and
relieve the child from drug abuse and other nature of criminality motivated by
the state of drug addiction.
PROTECTION OF THE CHILD AGAINST
CHILD TRAFFICKING
Trafficking of the
child is the global problem. The child is highly suffering from this kind of
abuse. Gallinetti J., & Kassan D., commenting on child trafficking
provides: ‘In particular, child trafficking is a deadly evil on account of the
fact that children are the most vulnerable to this ‘hidden crime’. Victims of
trafficking rarely have the opportunity to report their ordeals to the
authorities and children in this regard are the most disempowered. It is
therefore incumbent on states to provide practical as well as legal assistance
to children. However it has been noted that the magnitude of child trafficking
globally makes it clear that many states have been quite ineffectual in
protecting children from this particular phenomenon.’
It has been noted that, despite there are laws at various levels but the
child trafficking has not been stopped.
It is obvious that, the law criminalises any act relating to trafficking
of the child. Thus no person is allowed to engage in the act of buying,
selling, and bartering of any child for money or for any other
consideration. Likewise, the law makes
it an offence for any person to arrange or assist, a child to travel within or
outside Tanzania without the consent of the child’s parent or lawful
guardian. It is an offence to engage in
procuring the child from hospitals, shelters for women, clinics, nurseries, day
care centres, or any other child care institutions or welfare centres, for
money or other consideration or procures a child for adoption from any
institution or centre, by intimidation of the mother or any other person. Any person who does such acts commits the
offence of trafficking. Section 4(1)(a)
of the Anti-Trafficking in Persons Act, 2008
provides that: ‘A person commits an offence of trafficking in person if
that person- recruit, transports, transfers, harbours, provides or receives a
person by any means, including those done under the pretext of domestic or
overseas employment, training or apprenticeship, for the purpose of
prostitution, pornography, sexual exploitation, forced labour, slavery,
involuntary servitude or debt bondage.’
These acts are trafficking in person. In case there is any person convicted
for the offence of trafficking of the child should be liable for imprisonment
for a term of not less than twenty years and not exceeding thirty years. Other
than imprisonment, the court can order to pay a fine of not less than one
hundred thousand shillings and not exceeding three hundred thousand shillings
or to both the fine and imprisonment. Also in addition the court power to
impose compensation order as the court deems fit to be paid to the victim of
trafficking.
Under the process of handling the investigation and judicial proceedings,
the victim of drug trafficking in person has rights, which should be
confidentially handled. The private life and identify of victims of trafficking
in persons should be secured and protected.
The law enforcement organs, court personnel and medical practitioners,
as well as parties to the case at the stages of investigation and trial of
trafficking offence must recognise the right to privacy of the trafficked
person and the accused. But at any stage
the child is involved then the matter should be handled in camera. To this regard, the name and personal
particulars of the trafficked child or any other information regarding the
trafficked child should not be disclosed to the public. In the process of
protecting the information of the child the following person are not allowed
during the proceedings, such as: Editor, publisher, reporter, or
columnist; presenter or producer; producer or director of a film; any person utilising tri-media facilities or
information technology, to cause publicity of that prosecution. All these are done with a view of limiting
the information of the child to the public. Also obstruct the existence of
child records which will motivate the child to involve into tracking in person
when attains the age of adults.
In the process of protecting the child from being trafficked, the law gives
responsibility to the State to rescue, rehabilitate, protect, and provide a
useful assistance to the child victims of trafficking in persons. The public
officers in the security services should be responsible for the rescue mission
of a trafficked person. Their responsibilities also cover the provision of
temporary basic material which support for the care and protection of a rescued
victim of trafficking in persons. It is
essential to note that, social rehabilitation of rescued victims should be
carried out by social welfare officers for reinstating the victim back into
normal way of life. This include the
provision of' legal assistance and
material support in terms of psychological, medical and professional
rehabilitation. But where is necessary the child victim should be given light
employment and a dwelling place for the betterment of his life. However, a
number of children are not provided with legal assistance hence remains without
proper defence. Also such child victim
should be provided with the counseling services by the office of the Commissioner
for Social Welfare Officer with a view of assisting in the rehabilitation and
re-integration of the respective child.
During the entire process of dealing with the child victimised by
trafficking in persons the principle of the best interest of the child should
be paramount in any assistance given to the child. Such assistance can include
undertaking the rescue, rehabilitation, counseling or re-integration of a child
toward assuming the normal and the enjoyable life.
However, the law protecting the child rights in Tanzania seems to be not
efficient in combating the business of trafficking in persons especial the
child. This causes the internal and external traffickers remaining un-arrested,
unpunished, and unstopped from criminality.
The business of trafficking of the child causes the child to continue
being used into the industries, mining, plantations, fishing, prostitution, and
other hazardous activities and places. Therefore, efforts should be taken in
reviewing the law, law enforcers system, and providing appropriate educational
programmes with a view of acquiring better knowledge of child rights and
protection in Tanzania.
CONCLUSION
The child needs to
be protected from any circumstances of degrading treatment. Tanzania has
different laws protecting the rights of the child which have been enacted in
alliance with the international legal instruments for child rights. However,
the child experiences torture, involved in pornography and sexual practices,
involves in harmful labour, drug abuse and trafficking. In protecting the child
from such degrading treatment, Tanzania needs deliberate efforts in curbing the
mistreatment of the rights of the child in Tanzania including introducing
awareness to the public on the rights and welfare of the child.
REFERENCES
Byrne, I. (1998). The human rights of street and
working children, A practical manual for advocates, Intermediate Technology
Publications: United Kingdom.
Commission for Human Rights and Good
Governance. (2009). Children desk report for CRC
committee members and rapporteurs for the optional protocols, United Nations:
Dar es Salaam.
Gallinetti J., and Kassan, D. (2008). ‘Trafficking of children in Africa: an overview of research, international
obligations and existing legal provisions in J. S. Nielsen (ed.) children’s
rights in Africa: a legal perspective. Hampshire: Ashgate Publishing Limited.
Hellum, A, (2007), Human rights, plural legalities and gender realities, Southern
and Eastern African Regional Centre for Women’s Law: Harare.
Islam, Z., & Rahman,
M. (2015). Corporal punishment: the case of a child abuse
by a Malaysian couple in Sweden. Advances
in Environmental Biology, 9(17 S3), 9-12.
Kihwelo, P. F.
(2008). Child rights protection in Tanzania: a need for an immediate
harmonisation. 2 (2): 45.
Legal and Human Rights Centre, (2007). Human rights reports
2007 incorporating specific part on Zanzibar. Legal and Human Rights Centre:
Dar es Salaam.
Magobe, T. (2009). ‘ILO’S decent work agenda and its application in Tanzania’ 8 (1):
69.
Mambi, A. J.
(2009). Legal challenges on children protection in cyberspace in Tanzania a
comparative perspective’ (2009) 1(1): 85.
Mashamba, C.J. (2010), Introduction to family law in Tanzania, Institute of Public
Policy and the law & the National Organisation for Legal Assistance (nola): Dar es Salaam.
Mathur, K. M.(1996). Crime human rights and national
security, Gyan Publishing House: New Delhi.
Mkandya , B. 2008) ‘Is
traffic in human beings a crime in Tanzania?’ (2008) i-vi, nos 1- 6 (2006-2008)
the Justice Review, special consolidated edition to mark the 5th anniversary of
Nola, 66.
Paranjape, N. V. (2001). Criminology and penology, Allahbad: Central Law
Publications.
Peter, C. M. (1997). Human rights in Tanzania:
Selected Cases and Materials, Koppe: Kolon.
Shivji. I. G. (2004). Constitutional and legal system of
Tanzania, Mkuki na Nyota Publisher: Dar es Salaam.
Singh. D. (2001). Child rights and social wrongs, Kanishke Publisher: New Delhi.
T. Asuni (2004). ‘Drug trafficking and drug abuse in
Africa’ in T.M. Mushanga (ed.), Criminology in Africa, Fountain Publisher:
Kampala.
The Law Reform of Tanzania, (2006). Report on the introduction of a legal framework on electronic commerce and
cyber crimes, The Law Reform of Tanzania: Dar es Salaam.